Hours after Congress leader Manish Tewari on Thursday said the government might get the Digital Data Protection Bill classified as a money bill, Union IT Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw refuted the charge and termed it a "normal bill".
Tewari earlier in the day suggested that the Data Protection Bill should be considered a regular bill while noting that it should again go to a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC).
But as the bill was moved in the Lok Sabha, Union Minister for Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) Vaishnaw rejected the suggestions that it was a money bill and called it a "normal bill".
The bill aims at making entities such as internet companies, mobile apps, and business houses more accountable and answerable about the collection, storage and processing of data of citizens as part of the Right to Privacy.
"How did the Digital Data Protection Bill get classified as a financial bill suddenly," Tewari tweeted.
"It needs to be considered as a regular bill and go to a JPC again," he said.
"If this bill on passage is certified as a money bill by Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla which seems to be the intent of getting it classed as a financial bill then Rajya Sabha can not vote on it. It can only recommend non binding changes to Lok Sabha," the Congress MP from Punjab said.
"The previous bill that went to JPC was introduced as a normal bill. It also set up a Data Protection Authority. That too had financial implications. It was not classified as a financial bill. The intent here seems to be pretty clear. Once it is passed as a financial bill by the Lok Sabha the Hon'ble @loksabhaspeaker @ombirlakota in his innate wisdom can certify it as a money bill. After that the Rajya Sabha would have only recommendatory powers," he tweeted later.
"It does not require rocket science to figure out that Rajya Sabha could have sent it to the select committee given how the numbers were stacked," Tewari added.
He also shared a copy of the presidential order classifying the bill as a money bill, and said, "The latest iteration of this bill mocks the efforts put in by the Joint Committee of Parliament on the Data Protection Bill led by two BJP members P P Chaudhary and Meenakshi Lekhi respectively."
Government sources said President's assent had been sought as funds will be earmarked under the proposed law from the Consolidated Fund of India. They said the penalties that will come under the law and the expenditure on the staff required under the law will be under the Consolidated Fund of India.
The work on the data protection bill started after the Supreme Court ruled that the Right to Privacy is a fundamental right.
The government had in August last year withdrawn the personal data protection bill, which was first presented in late 2019 and issued a new version of the draft bill in November 2022.
The draft bill had earned criticism around the government getting the power to exempt entities from various clauses of the bill.
