Advertisement

Help
You are here: Rediff Home » India » News » Photos
Search:  Rediff.com The Web
A US Army soldier provides security from a tower at Forward Operating Base Lane in the Zabul province of Afghanistan. (Inset) William Dalrymple
 
      Discuss |    Email  |  Get latest news on desktop
   Print
Next
'The West allowed Afghanistan to rot'

'In the West, the Taliban is known for its medieval barbarism, public executions, stoning of women for adultery. But for many Afghans now, they are respectable -- as the Taliban provides security,' says noted writer William Dalrymple in a two part interview with rediff.com's Arthur J Pais.

Read Part I: 'Americans in Afghanistan know their game is over'

In the concluding part, Dalrymple also describes Indian involvement in Afghanistan as a major strategic error.

You fault the West for ignoring developmental work in Afghanistan

Whatever intentions the West had to improve the roads, schools, hospitals and other services in Afghanistan were forgotten by the focus on getting rid of Saddam Hussain in Iraq. Because of the obsession with Saddam, Afghanistan was allowed to rot. Obama could have changed the situation but he has been busy on the war front.

We had a real opportunity to show that we represented education and development. We could have proved that we were there for the Afghans and not just for our own sake. By helping the welfare of the Afghans, we could have demonstrated that we were not building a fortress there for our own strategic interests.

Despite the US pouring approximately $80 billion into Afghanistan, the roads in Kabul are still full of potholes. They are in a worse condition than in the smallest provincial towns of Pakistan. And this is true for most of Afghanistan. The health care is also nonexistent for most part.

Image: A US Army soldier provides security from a tower at Forward Operating Base Lane in the Zabul province of Afghanistan. (Inset) William Dalrymple
Photograph: Spc Tia P Sokimson/DoD photo
Also read: Be ready for a long haul in Afghanistan
What India needs to do in Afghanistan
India's goodwill and Pak's bluff in Afghanistan
Afghanistan: US should change tactics not generals
The Taliban is down but not out
Next
© 2009 Rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.Disclaimer | Feedback