The BJP's star campaigner could not help even half the number of candidates for whom he campaigned in his aggressive 'Didi-o-Didi' style in Bengal, reveals Rediff.com's Syed Firdaus Ashraf.
IMAGE: Narendra Damodardas Modi addresses an election rally at the BNR Ground, Kharagpur, in Bengal's West Midnapore district, March 20, 2021. Photograph: Swapan Mahapatra/ PTI Photo
Data compiled by Hemant Shivsharan/Rediff.com
'I have never before seen such a huge crowd. I am seeing it for the first time,' thundered Narendra Damodardas Modi at an election rally in Asansol, West Bengal.
'Wherever I see from stage, I see only people in front of me. Kya kamaal kar diya aap logo ne,' Modi, the Bharatiya Janata party's lead campaigner for Bengal's assembly election, declared..
Modi's remarks came under severe scrutiny on social media and in the international media as many felt that it was not right for the prime minister of India to brag about the swelling crowds at his rallies amid the surging COVID-19 crisis.
The crowd turnout was so large that many felt that the Modi magic would vanquish Mamata Banerjee and her All India Trinamool Congress.
The voters of Asansol Uttar, where Modi boasted about the huge crowds, voted for the TMC candidate.
BJP candidate Krishnendu Mukherjee lost to the TMC's Ghatak Moloy by 21,110 votes.
The only consolation prize that Modi's rally served was the BJP won Asansol Dakshin with Agnimitra Paul defeating Sayani Ghosh of TMC by 4,487 votes.
On April 3, Modi went to Tarakeshwar to address a rally for Swapan Dasgupta who days earlier had resigned from the Rajya Sabha to contest the Bengal assembly election.
Dasgupta -- who was mentioned as a likely chief minister if the BJP won Bengal -- was confident about his election victory.
TMC nominee Ramendu Sinharay defeated Dasgupta in Tarakeshwar by 7,484 votes.
In Howrah had Modi spoken about double engine growth at his rally.
'I request all young sons and daughters to help spread the word of 'asol poriborton' (real change) to their families and neighbours,' Modi said.
The result? All three seats -- Howrah Uttar, Howrah Madhya and Howrah Dakshin -- went to the TMC.
TMC won Howrah Dakshin by 50,569 votes; Howrah Madhya by 46,547 votes; Howrah Uttar by 5,522 votes.
Check out the strike rate of Modi's rallies.
Date |
Constituency |
Rally addressed by Modi |
Result |
BJP candidate |
TMC candidate |
Won by |
Lost by |
February 22 |
Haldia |
Public Meeting @ 4 pm |
Won |
Tapasi Mondal |
Swapan Naskar |
15,008 votes |
|
February 22 |
Chuchura, Hooghly |
Public Meeting Chuchura Dunlop Ground @ 3.45 pm |
Lost |
Locket Chatterjee |
Asit Mazumder (Tapan) |
|
18,417 votes |
March 7 |
Kolkata |
Brigade Cholo Rally, Brigade Parade Ground @ 2 pm |
Lost |
Awadh Kishore Gupta |
Firhad Hakim |
|
68,554 votes |
March 18 |
Purulia |
Public Rally @ 11 am |
Won |
Sudip Kumar Mukherjee |
Sujoy Banerjee |
7,018 votes |
|
March 20 |
Kharagpur |
Public Meeting, BNR Ground @ 11 am |
Lost |
Tapan Bhuya |
Dinen Roy |
|
36,230 votes |
March 21 |
Bankura |
Public Meeting, Tila Bediya Ground @ 3.30 pm |
Won |
Niladri Sekhar Dana |
Sayantika Banerjee |
1,468 votes |
|
March 24 |
Kanthi Uttar |
Kanthi Public Meeting @ 11 am |
Won |
Sumita Sinha (Kanthi Uttar) |
Tarun Kumar Jana |
9,330 votes |
|
Kanthi Dakshin |
Won |
Arup Kumar Das (Kanthi Dakshin) |
Jyotirmoy Kar |
10,293 votes |
|
April 1 |
Jaynagar |
Public Meeting @ 2.30 pm |
Lost |
Rabin Sardar |
Biswanath Das |
|
38,683 votes |
April 1 |
Uluberia Uttar |
Uluberia Public Meeting @ 4.00 pm |
Lost |
Chiran Bera |
Dr Nirmal Maji (Uluberia Uttar) |
|
21,003 votes |
Uluberia Purba |
Lost |
Pratyush Mandal |
Bidesh Ranjan Bose (Uluberia Purba) |
|
17,126 votes |
Uluberia Dakshin |
Lost |
Papia Dey (Adhikary) |
Pulak Roy (Uluberia Dakshin) |
|
28,438 votes |
April 3 |
Tarakeshwar |
Public Meeting @ 2.45 pm |
Lost |
Dr Swapan Dasgupta |
Ramendu Sinharay |
|
7,484 votes |
April 3 |
Sonarpur Uttar |
Sonarpur Public Meeting @ 4.15 pm |
Lost |
Ranjan Baidya |
Firdousi Begum (Sonarpur Uttar) |
|
36,090 votes |
Sonarpur Dakshin |
Lost |
Anjana Basu |
Arundhuti Maitra (Lovely) (Sonarpur Dakshin) |
|
26181 votes |
April 6 |
Cooch Behar Uttar |
Cooch Behar Public Meeting |
Won |
Sukumar Roy |
Binay Krishna Barman |
14,615 votes |
|
Cooch Behar Dakshin |
Won |
Nikhil Ranjan Dey |
Avijit De Bhowmik |
4,931 votes |
|
April 6 |
Howrah Uttar |
Public Meeting |
Lost |
Umesh Rai |
Gautam Chowdhuri |
|
5,522 votes |
Howrah Madhya |
Lost |
Sanjay Singh |
Arup Roy, S/o Late Prabhat Roy |
|
46,547 votes |
Howrah Dakshin |
Lost |
Rantidev Sengupta |
Nandita Chowdhury |
|
50,569 votes |
April 10 |
Siliguri |
Public Meeting @ 12.00 pm |
Won |
Sankar Ghosh |
Dr Omprakash Mishra |
35,586 votes |
|
April 10 |
Krishnanagar Uttar |
Public Meeting @ 3.15 pm |
Won |
Mukul Roy |
Koushani Mukherjee |
35,089 votes |
|
Krishnanagar Dakshin |
|
Lost |
Mahadev Sarkar |
Ujjal Biswas |
|
9,305 votes |
April 12 |
Bardhaman Uttar |
Public Rally @ 12 noon |
Lost |
Radha Kanta Roy |
Nisith Kumar Malik |
|
17,268 votes |
Bardhaman Dakshin |
Lost |
Sandip Nandi |
Khokan Das |
|
8,105 votes |
April 12 |
Kalyani |
Public Rally @ 1.45 pm |
Won |
Ambika Roy |
Aniruddha Biswas |
2,206 votes |
|
April 12 |
Barasat |
Public Rally @ 3.15 pm |
Lost |
Sankar Chatterjee |
Chiranjeet Chakrabarti |
|
23,783 votes |
April 17 |
Asansol Uttar |
Public Meeting @ 12 noon |
Lost |
Krishnendu Mukherjee |
Ghatak Moloy |
|
21,110 votes |
April 17 |
Asansol Dakshin |
|
Won |
Agnimitra Paul |
Sayani Ghosh |
4,487 votes |
|
April 17 |
Gangarampur |
Public Meeting @ 2.15 pm |
Won |
Satyendra Nath Ray |
Goutam Das |
4592 votes |
|
APRIL 23 |
Maldaha |
Addressed the voters through virtual channels. |
Won |
Gopal Chandra Saha |
Ujjwal Kumar Chowdhury |
15,456 votes |
|
APRIL 23 |
Murshidabad |
Addressed the voters through virtual channels. |
Won |
Gouri Sankar Ghosh |
Shaoni Singha Roy |
2,491 votes |
|
APRIL 23 |
Dubrajpur (SC) (Birbhum) |
Addressed the voters through virtual channels. |
Won |
Anup Kumar Saha |
Debabrata Saha |
3,863 votes |
|
Of the 33 seats where Modi campaigned, the BJP could win only 15 seats. Modi could not help even half the number of candidates for whom he campaigned in his aggressive 'Didi-o-Didi' style.
And if you add Birbhum district where Modi addressed just one rally, and in which an additional 11 assembly seats fall, the BJP won a lonely seat, Dubrajpur (SC).
And, in the six assembly constituencies of Bankura, Cooch Behar (Dakshin), Kalyani, Asansol (Dakshin), Gangarampur and Murshidabad, where Modi addressed rallies, the BJP candidates won by less than 5,000 votes.
Table designed by Ashish Narsale/Rediff.com