Rediff.com« Back to articlePrint this article

India a staunch critic of UDRS

Last updated on: June 6, 2011 12:06 IST
MS Dhoni asks for a Decision Review

The ICC Chief Executive Haroon Lorgat has admitted that the availability of technology has been an issue in the controversial Umpire Decision Review System and it is up to the Boards to decide on its use in the series among themselves.

"At present there are practical issues with the availability of technology and hence it is up to the respective Member Boards to decide if they wish to use DRS in any given series," Lorgat said.

"That will depend on the ICC Board," he said when asked about the universal use of UDRS.

India has been a staunch critic of the use of UDRS in bilateral series as it feels that decisions under the system are not 100 per cent accurate. It is not being used in the current full tour of India in the West Indies.

UDRS has increased correct decision-making

Last updated on: June 6, 2011 12:06 IST
Umpires await a decision

Lorgat, however, said that wherever the UDRS has been used it has increased in correct decision-making.

"We are very satisfied with the way DRS, which is pioneering technology, has progressed. No one doubts that it has helped to raise the percentage of correct decisions -- by more than five per cent from about 92 per cent to more than 97 per cent - and crucially it has removed the obvious umpiring errors.

"Even though such errors are rare thanks to the high level of performance by our elite umpires, they can and do occur from time to time. The DRS helps to remove these and allows the game to proceed without a blatant error becoming a lasting feature of the match," Lorgat said.

No window for IPL now

Last updated on: June 6, 2011 12:06 IST
Chennai Super Kings after winning the IPL4

Asked if the ICC could has thought about using sponsorship deals for 'hot-spot' and other technologies such as DRS, which would help them being available in all Test matches, Lorgat said, "Yes".

The BCCI-run Indian Premier League, in its fourth season now, has been immensely successful leading to many players demanding an international window but Lorgat made it clear that ICC is not considering any such proposal.

"The ICC manages international cricket, not domestic tournaments. No member has sought a window in the international schedule for any of its domestic competitions and nor has the ICC considered any such proposals," he said.

ICC satisfied with PCB

Last updated on: June 6, 2011 12:06 IST
Haroon Lorgat

Asked if the ICC was satisfied with the steps that have been taken by the PCB after the spot-fixing scandal that rocked world cricket, Lorgat said, "I believe the PCB is well aware of the seriousness of corruption in cricket and they are tackling the issues. The recent guilty verdict on the three players has resulted in the PCB taking a number of important steps to fight this scourge."

"It is not a problem confined to Pakistan. Corruption is a threat to all countries and can strike anywhere, so it's important we don't confine our attention to one or two places.

"There is no evidence to suggest that corruption is widespread in cricket but that does not mean we can be complacent. While I know the vast majority of players to be honest, we must always be on the lookout for anything that could harm the reputation or the integrity of cricket," he said.

ICC will revisit composition of WC 2015

Last updated on: June 6, 2011 12:06 IST

On the criticism on ICC over its decision to limit the number of teams for the next World Cup to 10, Lorgat said, "The criticism is understandable. However, it is for the ICC Board to decide what is in the best interest of the game.

"As previously announced, the Board will revisit the decisions made surrounding the composition of the ICC Cricket World Cup 2015 when it next meets (at the end of June in Hong Kong)," he added.