Graeme Smith's baptism to international cricket as captain was dealt a cruel blow as South Africa fell to their worst defeat against India in the second encounter of the TVS Cup in Dhaka.
The 153-run win confirmed India's place in the final of the tournament, which surprisingly has no prize-money for the winners and runners-up.
Two 22-year-olds had a point to prove in the match. Graeme Smith, leading the South African side for the first time, had to make an impression. Mohammad Kaif, struggling to middle the ball over the past few months, needed to come good and justify his place in the side.
52 overs into the game, skipper Smith was bowled for one. Kaif made 94 more runs and saw India cross the 300-run mark after skipper Ganguly won the toss and elected to bat.
The innings won Mohammad Kaif the man-of-the-match award and reaffirmed coach John Wright's faith in the youngster from Allahabad.
"Kaif is what winning is all about," the coach had said about Kaif. Today his unbeaten 95 did just that; it won the game for India.
Batting seems to come so easy for Indian batsmen these days that a wicket falling doesn't seem to matter. If 276 seemed huge against a side like Bangladesh, India went a step further and scored 307 against the South Africans.
Gautam Gambhir frittered another opportunity after getting in, when he edged Makhaya Ntini to the keeper for 18 well-made runs. Just looking good and showing promise won't cut it for Gambhir to cement his place in a squad, where tall scores are the norm. Ntini snapped his 100th one-day wicket and was the most impressive bowler for the first 20 overs of the Indian innings.
Smith came to Bangladesh with the reputation of being an attacking and radical captain. By not bringing on Shaun Pollock to bowl until the 20th over surely looked radical but was hardly attacking.
After Sehwag was reprieved, before he had opened his account, by Peter Robinson, at square leg, he and Ganguly coasted along at six an over, scoring 83 runs in the first 15 overs. Even though runs were gushing for India, Smith continued with greenhorns C Willoughby and Alan Dawson.
What kind team strategy would plan to keep the bowling spearhead out of the attack with the opposition rattling away at six runs an over? Add to that the fact that Pollock did not bowl his full quota of 10 overs. Besides the regular net sessions and training drills, the Proteas need some urgent arithmetic classes. The South Africans are in the chronic stage of the 'miscalculation syndrome', which saw them bow out of the World Cup in the first round.
In the post-match interview, Smith explained the move to have Pollock bowl in the middle, saying it was to bottle up the runs. Reading between the proverbial lines, it means Pollock is now going to play the role of stock bowler in the side. The sooner the South African think-tank rectifies this gaffe and throws the new ball back to Pollock, the better it will be for the side.
Sehwag misread a Dawson slower delivery and holed out to Jacques Rudolph at mid-on to the disgust of Ganguly, who shook his head in disbelief at the shot-selection, to make it 89-2. Sehwag will take some time to adapt to the new challenge of pacing his innings; something he has never done in his playing career. It is important to allow him to play his game instead of seeing him get out in the 30s and 40s more out of indecision than temperament.
Kaif and Ganguly got down to playing out the middle overs and sustaining the healthy run-rate of 5. Running the singles and twos regularly, Kaif kept the scoreboard moving steadily before Ganguly danced down the wicket and gave a quick lesson to left-arm spinner Peter Robinson about bowling to sub-continental