Rediff.com« Back to articlePrint this article

Indians in selection dilemma ahead of 3rd Test

June 21, 2006 14:17 IST

Under fire for their skewed selection policy in the first two matches, India were grappling with their bowling combination as they seek to break the series deadlock and go 1-0 up in the third cricket Test against the West Indies starting tomorrow.

Riled much by former cricketers and media back home for missing an extra bowler in the preceding two Tests which it could well have won, the Indian team management is choosing defiance over commonsense ahead of the crucial encounter.

Coach Greg Chappell began the tour as a promoter of five-bowler theory but now asserts that he wants to make sure his batsmen make big runs to pressurise the opposition, never mind if it is only four men manning the attack.

Captain Rahul Dravid is singing the same tune and swearing by four bowlers who nearly did the job in the last game. He is taking a lot of heart from how Virender Sehwag bowled in the last Test in St Lucia.

While the Indian team did everything but pull the noose in the first two games, it probably missed offspinner Harbhajan Singh in the attack whose stock delivery leaves the left-hander of whom there are at least three in the top six of the West Indian line-up.

"In an ideal scenario, we would have liked to have five bowlers but Veeru has done the job for us. He adds extra string in the bow for us," Dravid said after the nets yesterday.

Chris Gayle, Brian Lara and Shivnarine Chanderpaul are all left-handers and could have found Harbhajan a greater challenge than Sehwag, however promising he might have been in the first two Tests.

Dravid and Chappell would be joined by Kiran More, chairman of national selectors who landed in St Kitts yesterday, to decide the playing eleven.

The pitch, which sported some green tinge in the centre, would also be a factor in the decision over the team combination.

ICC's pitch expert Andy Atkinson was specially flown in at the instance of home captain Lara who wanted a seamer-friendly wicket to contain the inform Indian batsmen.

But Atkinson was convinced the track would have nothing for the bowlers except for a bit of bounce.

As clouds encircled the pretty stadium once again in the afternoon, he hoped it would stay away to allow pitch to harden to the extent he wants.

The dilemma of the Indian think-tank certainly has kept the likes of Yuvraj Singh and VVS Laxman on the edge and they must await an official word which could either confirm their worst fears or bring them relief.

Indian batsmen would relish the prospect of facing up to the mediocre home bowling on a pitch which should suit their strokeplay and the short boundaries which could carry even a mishit for the maximum.

Both Yuvraj and VVS Laxman would be itching to have one more opportunity to atone for their earlier failures.

Yet the logic of playing only five specialist batsmen is difficult to gloss over, especially since Wasim Jaffer, Virender Sehwag, Rahul Dravid and Mohammed Kaif have all hit centuries in the present series.

But India would be making a mistake if it feels the likes of Gayle, Chanderpaul and Sarwan could fail one another time. They have considerable reputation in international circuit and odds are in their favour to hit form before long.

They are perfectly capable of showing up the inexperienced Indian bowling attack.

Lara would be chastened by his recent experience with the selectors. He was saddled with the same set of bowlers even as he went public to ask for a fast bowler of his liking.

He still is likely to favour Marlon Samuels ahead of opener Daren Ganga in the squad as the former is also a useful customer with his offspinners.

Ganga has done little of note in the first two Tests and must face yet another axe in his already chequered career.

The weather isn't too promising at the venue during the Test though the locals aver it is impossible to predict correct weather for the island.

One of the smallest yet neatest of all Caribbean islands, St Kitts is a mere speck on the world map and one only tends to get general weather for the region.

According to such observations, the first three days of the Test would see a lot of grey and black clouds but it actually wouldn't be so threatening.

There is bigger threat of rain on the final two days. If rain indeed plays its hands, Dravid would have reasons to feel frustrated.

The teams (from among):

India: Rahul Dravid (captain), Virender Sehwag, Wasim Jaffer, VVS Laxman, Yuvraj Singh, Mohammed Kaif, Mahendra Singh Dhoni, Harbhajan Singh, Anil Kumble, Irfan Pathan, Munaf Patel, VRV Singh, Suresh Raina and Sreesanth.

West Indies: Brian Lara (captain), Chris Gayle, Daren Ganga, Marlon Samuels, Ramnaresh Sarwan, Shivnarine Chanderpaul, Dwayne Bravo, Denesh Ramdin, Ian Bradshaw, Corey Collymore, Pedro Collins and Jerome Taylor.

Umpires: Brian Jerling and Rudi Koerzten (SA)

Match referee: Jeff Crowe (NZ).

Ashish Shukla
© Copyright 2024 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.