 | « Back to article | Print this article |
'The talk is all about strike rates but for Test match cricket that is a load of rubbish.'
Former captain Geoffrey Boycott slammed the England batsmen for showing lack of patience and technique in the rain-hit first Test against India, which finished in a draw.
Boycott feels some of the batsmen can't resist the temptation of poking at the ball when it is not meant to be hit and said too much focus on one-day cricket is adding to their struggles.
Skipper Joe Root was only England batsmen who made an impact in the series-opener, scoring 109 and 64 in his two innings.
"I recently bumped into Graham Gooch and we chatted about England's batting. He summed it all up by saying: 'Fiery, if bowlers keep it tight for four balls, then you know our batsmen will have a go at the fifth and sixth deliveries and there is every chance they will get themselves out'," Boycott said in his column in The Telegraph.
"The culture of cricket has changed. Many of us batsmen love playing shots and because of the diet of one day cricket, modern players are pretty good at it, but it is their defensive technique that lets them down.
"It might sound unfashionable because of franchise leagues to talk about staying in and being defensive but, like Goochie said, teams only have to bowl a few good balls because they know batsmen will soon be tempted to play a big shot."
England's batsmen had also struggled in the preceding home series against New Zealand.
"We supporters are disappointed when they look to attack all the time, but we should not be surprised, because that is the type of cricket they have been taught at county level.
"Look at Zak Crawley. He is symptomatic of the problem. Over the last number of years young batsmen have been taught to whack the ball because there are so many one day matches," lamented Boycott.
"The talk is all about strike rates but for Test match cricket that is a load of rubbish. If you can't defend, then top bowlers in Test match cricket with a newish ball will find your weaknesses. What is the point of having a range of eye-catching strokes if you can't stay in? That is the root cause of his problems."
He also had a go at opener Rory Burns and Dom Sibley.
"Not just former Test players but even club players look at Rory Burns and Dom Sibley and think they can do better.
"Sibley is the opposite of Crawley. He has stickability but his lack of strokes hurts him. He cannot rotate the strike, so if he cannot move his score along, and the team's score, then he creates enormous pressure on himself.
"Burns is like Sibley. First innings he lasted five balls. It was a repeat of previous dismissals. He started his front foot forward on the wrong side of the ball and then realised he had picked the wrong length," said Boycott.
Then came the turn of Jos Buttler and Dan Lawrence.
"I don't know what to say about Dan Lawrence. It is just footwork with him. They have to find someone else.
"Jos Buttler is a sad tale. In the first innings he got nought off 18 balls and could have been out about seven times. His footwork and judgement were non-existent, but it is not surprising because he has not played any four-day matches.
"Many of our batsmen don't get enough preparation before Tests with proper county cricket.
"I don't think our administrators understand how difficult it can be to transfer the mental approach and way of batting from trying to hit every ball to the different tempo and technique required for Test matches," he added.