Mohammed Siraj's omission from India's Champions Trophy squad has ignited a firestorm of criticism, with fans and pundits questioning the selection committee's decision.
While the official explanation cites a preference for newcomer Harshit Rana, many believe Siraj's experience and consistent performances should have secured him a spot in the 15-man team. His absence has only intensified the debate over India's team balance and strategy for the marquee tournament.
Siraj's stats highlight his reliability as a proven wicket-taker. The pacer has 71 wickets in 43 ODIs at an average of 24.04, making him one of India's most effective bowlers in recent years.
He played a key role in India's 2023 World Cup campaign, picking up 14 wickets, and was instrumental in the Asia Cup final against Sri Lanka, where he tore through the batting lineup with figures of 6/21.
In January 2023, he held the No. 1 spot in the ICC ODI bowling rankings.
In contrast, Rana, who has just two ODIs to his name, impressed on debut against England with figures of 3/53 but struggled in the second game, conceding 62 runs in nine overs.
His selection over Siraj has left many puzzled, with critics arguing that India should have prioritised experience in a high-stakes tournament rather than taking a gamble on a newcomer.
Adding to the controversy, India also dropped young opener Yashasvi Jaiswal, opting instead to bring in spinner Varun Chakaravarthy.
With this change, India now has five specialist spinners -- Kuldeep Yadav, Chakaravarthy, Ravindra Jadeja, Axar Patel and Washington Sundar -- but only three frontline pacers in Mohammed Shami, Arshdeep Singh and Harshit Rana. Hardik Pandya remains the only seam-bowling all-rounder in the squad.
Fans and analysts have taken to social media to slam the selection committee, led by Ajit Agarkar, and Head Coach Gautam Gambhir for what they see as an unbalanced squad. One irate fan wrote, 'What a messy selection. Five spinners, Siraj ignored for Rana, and Jaiswal dropped. Brain-faded captain and coach combo!'
The decision is even more baffling given that India is already weakened by the absence of Jasprit Bumrah, who was withdrawn from the squad due to concerns over his match fitness.
While replacing Bumrah was inevitable, picking Rana over Siraj -- who played in the ODI World Cup and has proven himself in high-pressure games -- is difficult for fans to digest.
Making matters worse, Siraj was only included as a traveling reserve, raising further questions about the selectors' thought process.
The preference for additional spin options over a battle-tested pacer is being seen as a risky gamble, one that could potentially backfire if India's pace attack struggles in crucial matches.
With the tournament set to be played in the UAE, where pitches tend to favor spinners, the selection committee may have prioritised spin-friendly conditions over overall squad balance. But was this a well-thought-out strategic move, or has Siraj been unfairly overlooked?
As the debate rages on, one thing is clear -- the pressure is now on Gambhir, Agarkar, and the Indian team to justify their bold choices on the field.
© 2025